
LibraryThing is pleased to sit down this month with bestselling author Saratoga Schaefer, whose recent horror and thriller novels have caused quite a stir. Born in Brooklyn, they currently live in upstate New York, and made their authorial debut in 2025 with Serial Killer Support Group, described by author Dea Poirier as “a twisty and vicious thriller that will have you hungry for revenge.” 2026 publications include Trad Wife, The Last Time We Drowned, and A Thousand Monstrous Forms, a sapphic retelling of the horrific tale of Bluebeard in which a newly-married young woman must fight for her very survival. Schaefer sat down with Abigail this month to discuss A Thousand Monstrous Forms, published by Crooked Lane Books earlier in September.
Tell us about A Thousand Monstrous Forms. How did the idea first come to you? Did you always know it was going to be a retelling of Bluebeard?
A Thousand Monstrous Forms is a sapphic gothic horror Bluebeard retelling about a ceramic artist named Poppy Reed who moves into her new wife’s manor only to suspect it might be haunted. When she’s forbidden from entering the basement, Poppy finds herself drawn there over and over again.
This book was always going to be a Bluebeard retelling because I’ve always been strangely fascinated by the original folktale. But the impetus behind this book actually came many years ago when I took a medieval literature class in college. I read Edmund Spenser’s The Faerie Queene and fell in love with it, knowing I wanted to incorporate it into my own work one day. It took a long time to discover the bones of this book, but once I did, it came together in a way that really felt like kismet.
What is the significance of the Bluebeard story? Does recasting Bluebeard as a woman, and making the tale a sapphic one, change that story?
There are a lot of hints, nods, and easter eggs regarding the Bluebeard folktale in this book. It’s a retelling, so I wanted to be mindful of its source material while still creating a new story, especially one for the modern age. The theme of this book—realizing and recovering from abusive relationships—very much plays into the themes of the original Bluebeard. Making all the key characters women, and making the romance sapphic, was interesting because I got to explore new layers (such as queer partner abuse) not touched on in the original. Readers might be surprised to find how much that change affects the overall story…or not.
Can you elaborate on how you used Edmund Spenser’s The Faerie Queene in this book, and on any other influences in your story? Were there other classic tales that have shaped your book?
Spenser’s The Faerie Queene is a huge part of this book and brought all the themes and motifs together. I was researching Bluebeard and trying to figure out if there was a way I could also incorporate The Faerie Queene because I loved it so much. Imagine my surprise to discover that Spenser’s epic poem predates some of the iterations of the Bluebeard tale and might have even been the inspiration behind it. These two stories came together perfectly, allowing me to write my own. There are tons of references to The Faerie Queene within this book, including its title. Those who are familiar with the epic poem are going to see lots of winks and outright references and homages to the work within this book.
Your book speaks to issues of abuse and emotional trauma. What advantage does the horror genre offer to the storyteller, when exploring such themes?
Horror doesn’t shy away from darkness. In fact, horror is all about embracing the dark, analyzing it and compounding it until it’s even darker. Or until you feel some kind of catharsis from synthesizing your own pain in such a way. We sometimes think of horror as supernatural only—the things that go bump in the night or the monsters under the bed. But, for me, the true horror in all my books isn’t necessarily the spooky beings or jump-scares. It’s the humanity, the social aspect. How easy it is for us to hurt each other and how scarring that can be.
Tell us a little bit about your writing process. Do you have a particular schedule you keep, or rituals you observe? Do you know how your stories will end, when first beginning to write them?
I’m a morning writer for sure. I’m also a fast, intense drafter who needs to work in absolute silence. No background music for me—I get too distracted. Over many years I trained myself to write my first drafts in a little over a month because I learned that if I don’t get it done fast, I won’t get it done at all. I basically write two to three thousand words a day until the first draft is done, then I spend months (or sometimes years!) editing and revising. When I start to write, I always know how my stories will begin and end, but sometimes things in the middle change based on how the plot unfolds. Or if the characters decide to misbehave.
You’ve burst onto the scene recently, with four books in two years. What comes next for you? Do you have books in the offing that you can tell us about?
I didn’t initially plan on having three books out in one year, but since I’ve been writing novels for over a decade, I ended up with multiple manuscripts ready to go after my debut came out. I’m hoping to slow down a bit—eventually. I have two more announced projects I can currently talk about: my next psychological thriller, She’s a Big Fan, which comes out June 8, 2027, is about a fire-eater who notices strange behavior and disappearances at a pop star’s annual music festival; and Zeroth, my first sci-fi novel, out January 2028, about a starving artist who signs up for an android boyfriend beta test only to grow concerned by his dangerous malfunctions. Stay tuned…I’ll have some more news to share soon too!
Tell us about your library. What’s on your own shelves?
I’m a pretty diverse and eclectic reader; I like to read widely across genres. While of course I have a ton of thrillers and horror on my shelves, I also read sci-fi, fantasy, romance, literary fiction, and the occasional non-fiction. I’ve been on a cozy fantasy kick lately—fall makes me want to feel all warm and fuzzy inside.
What have you been reading lately, and what would you recommend to other readers?
I recently read E.L. Chen’s February 2027 horror release, One of Us Is Already Dead, and I couldn’t get enough of it. It’s so genuinely creepy. When a book freaks me out, I can’t stop smiling. Speaking of, I’m currently reading Clay McLeod Chapman’s March 2027 release, Mr. Lonelyhearts, which is so delightfully unsettling. Some of my top reads from 2026 that I’d definitely recommend are Sarah Wang’s New Skin, P. Paramita’s Appetite, and Luke Dumas’ Nothing Tastes as Good.


























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































![The Sagebrush Ocean: A Natural History of the Great Basin [35th Anniversary Edition]](https://pics.cdn.librarything.com/picsizes/17/51/17514272-b-h800-w400-pv25_5969412f4377475141534144_v5.jpg)
























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































