
LibraryThing is pleased to sit down this month with author and romance enthusiast Katie Holt, whose 2024 debut, Not In My Book, follows the stormy relationship between a romance novelist and a literary author who are forced to work together on a book. A New York City resident and Tennessee native, Holt earned her degree in English and Creative Writing at NYU, while working at famed Manhattan bookstore, The Strand. When not writing, she works at St. Martin’s Press as an assistant editor. Her second novel, The Last Page, about the romance between a bookseller who dreams of running the bookstore where she works and the owner’s oblivious grandson who has inherited everything, is due out from Alcove Press later in May. Holt sat down with Abigail this month to discuss her new book.
How did the idea for The Last Page first come to you? Were you inspired by your own time as a bookseller? (Full disclosure: I also worked at The Strand for a number of years). Were other bookstore romances, like the one in You’ve Got Mail, an influence?
A fellow Strand-er!! That’s so cool! We’ll definitely have to see if we crossed paths with any of the same booksellers.
I was definitely inspired by my time there. I think it’d be impossible not to be! The Strand has a rich history and while I worked there, lots of the booksellers told me stories about Ben McFall. They had nothing but wonderful things to say about them and it was obvious he left such a deep mark on The Strand. I thought a lot about what it meant to leave behind a legacy in a bookstore. To be surrounded by books and for him to really be the most talked. I never met him, of course, so Leo was really inspired by my late grandfather. He was the coolest person I’ve ever met in my entire life and was a huge reader and supporter of literature.
I’m sure you know that the group of booksellers at The Strand were opinionated and eclectic and I loved it. I’m still friends with so many booksellers there and adore them. The bookseller relationships and dynamics were inspired by them for sure.
Nora Ephron is one of my greatest inspirations, so totally! You’ve Got Mail also has such a fun crew that are all different from each other, but they come together to create some hilarious scenes. I’ve always loved Notting Hill, too, and how that small shop just seems to be bursting with books. The Last Page has plenty of room in their store, but in my mind, books are just spilling over every edge of every surface.
You’ve been a romance advocate in both your professional and academic life, arguing to your college professors that the genre was worthy of consideration. What makes romance so special to you, and why should readers pay attention to it?
Oh goodness, I could wax poetic for days. I always say my favorite part of the romance genre is the HEA (happily ever after). That readers are guaranteed a safety net and it allows writers to explore some really heavy topics! The Last Page discusses grief throughout—what it means to different people, how it can ebb and flow, and how it doesn’t always make sense. Henry is also someone who suffers from depression and feels really embarrassed about it. I loved that I could discuss these topics the way I wanted to and tell the reader, “Don’t worry. They’re safe and you are, too.”
A lot of the time in college, I was told that these character arcs or plots I wrote were devalued by interweaving a love story that ends happily. I had one professor who always said, “I don’t buy it. I don’t buy that all the characters you write end up together.” Well, they do! It always blew my mind. Why would love decrease the value of anything? Isn’t it beautiful that you can evolve and change and grow and fall in love with someone who’s watched all of that happen? Who loves you before, after, and throughout?
There’s also something really special about how the romance genre varies so much within the genre. To me, it demonstrates how everyone views love differently and how everyone loves differently. I just think it’s beautiful and something special and worthy of celebrating.
The Last Page features a bookseller from New York City and a bookstore owner from Tennessee—a profession and two places that have been important to you personally. Are there specific spots or incidents in Ella and Henry’s tale that were inspired by your own life story?
I’m definitely inspired by my life in the city, and it’s impossible for me to not write about the things happening around me. (However, I unfortunately didn’t fall in love with a hot, shy, nerdy former football player while working at The Strand). New York is such a romantic city and I work hard to make the city feel like a character in the book. A reader
tagged me in a NOT IN MY BOOK book tour they did across NYC when they were visiting and I burst into tears. Those pictures of them at Peculiar Pub and Washington Square Park were exactly why I include real restaurants and locations. Specifically in this book, Ella and Henry go to Kingston Hall, which is one of my favorite places. It’s buy one get one free beer on the weekends!! And there’s a great pool table and such interesting interior design. I’ve brought my laptop there plenty of times to get some writing done and thought it was such a cool place for them to stumble into.
Although I loved being a bookseller, I did have the quintessential yet frustrating “I saw a book with a black cover here three weeks ago. Can you help me find it?” which I include in The Last Page. Bill Clinton also did come in and sift through American History. There wasn’t a naked man that ran through the store—he had on a speedo in real life.
Something that was really inspired by my life was Leo. Like I said, he was based on my grandfather who I was really close to. He had been pretty sick for a few years and every time I saw him, I braced myself because it could’ve been the last. The thought of losing him haunted me and I think I wrote this in a place of nearly preemptive grief? I kind of think of it like a letter from my past self telling me that I’ll survive losing him, even if it hurts like hell sometimes. He never got to hold a copy of The Last Page, though, I know he would’ve been proud and read every single word (as he mortifyingly told me he did with Not In My Book).
Tell us a little bit about your writing process—how and where you like to write, and how you construct your stories. Are you a plotter or a pantser?
I have to plot. I recently finished writing a book that I tried to pants and it was horrible. I hated every single second of it, deleted everything, and started over.
My process has evolved as my life has! For Not In My Book, I was home for the pandemic and wrote the first draft in my childhood bed and my parent’s kitchen table. I had to have my Beats on and a bag of BBQ chips and Kombucha by my side (in my head they counteracted each other??).
Nowadays, though, I love to write in cafes or bars in the city. I’ve always thought it was very Cool Girl when I saw people writing or reading at bars. Recently, I’ve been grabbing my notebook and physically writing out scenes or chapters. I also love to listen to music while I write (mostly Taylor Swift) and think about how the characters fit that song or if they ever have. Because Rosie definitely listened to “Welcome to New York” for a month straight when she moved to New York and Ella definitely had “Honey” on a constant loop.
What advice would you give to up-and-coming authors, particularly up-and-coming romance authors?
When I was in high school, I took a writing course with Rachel Carter and it completely transformed the way I wrote and my perspective on it. She told me to write as much as I read and read a lot. The only way to know the mechanics of the genre or even a book is to completely entrench yourself in it. Read lots and lots of books and write every day. Even if it’s just a sentence! Writing is a muscle and if you don’t exercise it, it’ll weaken.
I also think it’s important to give yourself grace. No one is publishing their very first draft. It’s okay for your writing to be terrible and make sense to no one else but you. Sometimes it’s all in the revisions! But don’t be too hard on yourself.
What’s next for you? Do you have any books currently in the works?
I have a couple of things in the works!! I’m working on two books right now that are very different from each other. I don’t want to reveal too much just yet, but these really feel like the stories I’ve been waiting to tell for sometime, so I’m super excited about them!
Tell us about your library. What’s on your own shelves?
All kinds of romance! I really don’t shy away from any of the subgenres. I’ve been into speculative and dark recently, but I’m hoping historical makes a resurgence, especially now that Lisa Kleypas is back!
It’s really rare I read outside of romance, but that’s my small goal for this year. I’ve always been a physical reader, but I’m dabbling in some book club fiction and nonfiction through my audiobooks.
What have you been reading lately, and what would you recommend to other readers?
I just finished Tessa Bailey’s new time travel romance, Broken Rival, and I feel like I’m having a parasocial relationship with them. Like…it’s that serious. A Little Buzzed by Alys Murray was so intensely sexy that my Apple Watch asked if I was working out because my heartbeat was so high. That is a MUST read! I also read The Heartbreak Hotel by Ellen O’Clover recently and was stunned by it and the musings on love and life after a breakup. The characters are so well drawn and she strikes the exact right balance of emotionally intense and absolute yearning. Secret Nights and Northern Lights by Megan Oliver is also what second chance romance dreams are made of. I cannot wait to read more from her.












