
LibraryThing is pleased to sit down this month with best-selling author Shelley Noble, whose many novels run the gamut from historical fiction to mystery to contemporary women’s fiction. A former professional dancer, Noble toured with Twyla Tharp Dance and American Ballroom Theater, and has worked as a choreographer for film and theater productions. She earned her BFA and MFA at the University of Utah, and taught at California State University in Fresno. A former president of Sisters-in-Crime, Noble is a member of Mystery Writers of America, Romance Writers of America, and Liberty States Fiction Writers, and currently lives in New Jersey. Her newest novel, The Sisters of Book Row, was published by William Morrow in March 2026 and tells the story of three sisters and bookstore proprietors who confront the Comstock laws in 1915 Manhattan. Noble sat down with Abigail this month to discuss the book.
How did the story idea for The Sisters of Book Row first come to you? Were you drawn to the thought of writing about bookstores and booksellers, or perhaps about the Comstock laws?
I’ve had Comstock in the back of my mind for a while, a perfect villain, a vicious zealot, one who I particularly despise. So when my editor suggested I write a book about books, guess who came to mind. And because I write about Manhattan, I knew the perfect place in which to set the story, Book Row, once the mecca of rare and used book buyers from around the world. And like a magnet, this germ of an idea began collecting bits and pieces. An article about the current Cohen sisters of the Argosy Book Store inspired me to create the Applebaum sisters, and Sisters was born.
Tell us about the Comstock laws. What were they, and what effect did they have on the world of books and booksellers, as well as the wider American society of that time?
Anthony Comstock moved to New York in the early 1870s and was appointed special agent to The Society for the Suppression of Vice and the U.S. Post Office to prevent pornography from being sent through the mail. He was given the power to search, seize, arrest and fine, the monies of which he received half. His activities quickly spread to all facets of life, and as his power grew, his ideas of what was “obscene, lewd, or lascivious,” changed, sometimes from week to week. Later in his career, his extreme and outlandish views made him a laughing stock, ridiculed by the newspapers, and dismissed by the courts. The Post Office fired him, but he refused to leave. The NYSPV replaced him, but again he ignored them and continued on his crusade. The Comstock Act, enacted in 1873, included a ban on contraception and was written by Comstock himself. It was never repealed, but Roe v. Wade relegated it to being a zombie law. Unfortunately states had adopted the original law for their own use. And today we see it being used to prevent birth control information, or any reproductive health measures from all women. A zealot, who is said to have destroyed 15 tons of books and four million pictures and other materials, who hated women and died ridiculed and despised, and yet he has managed to rear his ugly head again today.
Your story is set on Book Row, a district in lower Manhattan that contained over three dozen bookstores at its height. Did you have to do any research about the history of the area, and what were some interesting things you learned? If you could visit any bookstore from that period, which would it be? (Disclosure: I worked for the Strand bookstore—the sole survivor of Book Row—for many years).
I used to hang out at the Strand all the time. Many years ago. It was a solace and an adventure away from the chaos of the city and my profession as a young dancer. I hope my Sisters of Book Row can come to life for readers of today. I did loads of research, I always do. It’s one of my favorite parts of writing historical fiction. There’s a lovely book titled Book Row by Marvin Mondlin and Roy Meador. It didn’t have as much information on my particular period 1915 as I hoped, but it was fascinating to read about the continuation of this community, especially post 1930.
Once I get an overview of my time and place and characters, I like to depend mainly on primary sources, newspapers, anecdotes, letters. That way I know what they know, feel what they feel, and try to leave my historical outsider’s knowledge at the door. I mostly learned the neighborhood in bits and pieces since the area has built up so much since then.
Some oddities and coincidences: The Argosy, owned by Louis Cohen, the father of the Cohen sisters who added their inspiration to this story had his own run in with “Comstockery” in the 1930s. When the city began digging the new subway, customers couldn’t get around construction, and many stores had to move uptown, then moved back in when it was completed. After I developed and had lived with my three Applebaum sisters and the Arcadia for weeks and several chapters, I learned that there was actually a Mr. Applebaum who had a bookshop in the Row, named Arcadia. Did I read about it and forgot while it became ingrained in my subconscious? Or was it really a coincidence? I was too attached to my own Applebaums to change their names, so I mentioned the existence of two families in my Author Notes.
Sometimes a story is like a jigsaw puzzle, learning a phrase, a sentence about the inhabitants. The two booksellers, who were constantly arguing, gave me an image that led to the daily morning conversations around the newsstand. They might have argued and complained, but they were neighbors and they were ready to take up a collection to bail one of their own out of jail when Comstock was on the prowl.
The book world has been rocked in recent years by an upsurge of attempts at censorship and book suppression. I chronicle some of that in the Freedom of Expression column of our monthly State of the Thing newsletter. What can your story tell us about our situation today, in this respect?
For our modern selves, I wish The Sisters of Book Row and their withstanding the attacks of what they loved most was so outside of our experience, so unbelievable, that readers might say. “Oh, that would never happen here.” But unfortunately we see it happening throughout our country by those who, like Comstock, denounce books they’ve never even read and bully those who only want to share knowledge. Their attacks sometimes seem so diffuse and widespread that we might think it will never affect us. It will, but I have to believe that we’re more experienced, more aware of the rotten core of the book banning movement, and that if we keep up a constant resistance, we will prevail.
Tell us a little bit about your writing process. Do you have a particular routine—a schedule you keep, or a place you like to write? You write in a number of different genres, does your story-building process differ, depending on the genre?
I do have a routine though it has changed over the years and books. When I wrote two books a year, I had a tighter schedule. Now that I’m writing one historical I can linger in the research, jump down a rabbit hole or two. And I find that writing of the past, I’ve changed from being an early morning writer, to a late night writer. There’s something about the dark and the quiet that I find conducive to delving into the past. Of course the nearer I get to deadline, the more daytime writing I have to do. I have a home office where I write all my books. Each genre requires a different energy and attitude. The contemporaries don’t require as much deep dive research, so I can begin writing sooner than with the historicals. No matter the genre, I depend on a storyboard to keep everything on track. Not a computer screen board but a big gridded Lucite board on the wall with color coded post-its for characters and plot points that can be moved around as the story develops.
What comes next for you? Are there any new books you’re currently working on?
I’m currently working on a story that takes place in 1870 Long Branch, New Jersey, where President Grant has his summer capital and a young woman aspiring to become a lawyer confronts the changes and the scandals that threaten the quiet seaside town she calls home.
Tell us about your library. What’s on your own shelves?
Lots of history books, mainly early 20th century New York, late 19th American theatre books when the Rialto was Union Square. Dickens, Austen, Mary Stewart. A rotation of women’s historical fiction. Eastern religion. Mystery and science fiction. I’m a pretty eclectic reader.
What have you been reading lately, and what would you recommend to other readers?
This fall I decided to go on a rereading spree. I started with Fahrenheit 451 followed by 1984 right before the holidays. Yes, they are still as scary as when I read them in school. After that, I immediately pulled out my favorite chapters of The Pickwick Papers. Now I’m re-rereading The Hobbit, and reading A Founding Mother** about Abigail Adams, by Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie. I highly recommend all of these.
**Stay tuned for our interview with Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie this coming July, in honor of America’s 250th birthday!












